Dirt Talk Blog


Where Are Our "˜Replacement Workers?'

October 2, 2012
/ Print / Reprints /
ShareMore
/ Text Size+


Whether you’re a knowledgeable football fan (Go Steelers!) or a casual observer, most of you are aware of the recent turmoil created by the use of replacement refs in the NFL. Poor calls ended up deciding some games, and the integrity of the sport as a whole was jeopardized.

Watching these poorly officiated games, it became very clear to me how important it is to have trained professionals in every position within an organization in order to experience true business success. An entire organization can suffer if even one aspect is not up to par. Whether in the NFL or in the construction industry, this notion holds true and is a relevant topic as we forge ahead.

Construction professionals-whether in the field or office, trades or management, engineering or administration-should all be highly trained to make decisions regarding policies, acts or events that can have a great impact to the organization. These skills are gained through education, hands-on experience, practice and repetition. However, what happens when most of our crews are relatively inexperienced, such as the refs?

Currently, we face such a dilemma within our construction industry. According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (March 2012), construction is projected to be one of the fastest growing job sectors through 2020, rising by 33 percent and adding 1.8 million jobs. While this is certainly great news, there is a not-so-silver lining that the construction industry faces-a well-documented shortage of skilled workers within both the trades and project management.

Due to factors including the economic downturn, our aging workforce and the insufficient pipeline of younger workers, many skill sets that will aid in the successful growth of our industry are lacking. Many of our peers have left the industry, and many training and apprentice programs needed to replace these workers have been severely cut back.  In my geographic area, industries such as the Marcellus Shale have grabbed up and trained many of these workers, leaving us without suitable replacements. The Marcellus industry systematically engaged in outreach, recruiting and training efforts down to the grassroots level (hint, hint), enabling them to find workers with a high likelihood of success.

Contrast this to the construction industry-where training and outreach slowed, and the number of workers entering the industry declined-and we now face a worker shortage. With greater demand for professionals of all types and a need for increased hiring, what are we to do? How can we avoid being saddled with an influx of “replacement workers” that may negatively impact our bottom lines as a result of their lack of training and skills?

I look forward to hearing some of your thoughts and solutions, which I will share along with some of my opinions in an upcoming blog. I am honored to be speaking on this topic as part of a panel discussion at the upcoming Associated General Contractors of America (AGC) Training Professionals Conference in San Antonio on Oct. 15 and look forward to sharing some of our possible solutions there as well.
You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Labor shortage

Sean Wynne
October 3, 2012
I live up here in N.Y there does not seem to be any shortage of skilled and non-skilled labor here,possibly the opposit.What i do see is contractors would rather use non-skilled and pay cheap disregaurding the conseqeunces.They are not willing to pay the extra for quality skilled workers.Ive been out of work for a 1 1/2 it is a joke here.

Worker Shortage

Bill Triplett
October 3, 2012
Needs to begin early in the education process. Students must be shown there are many great technical degrees and hands on certificates not requiring 4 year colleges. Seems as if college counselors get bonuses if kids go to 4 year college where many waste money and time. Trades must be reflected as a good career choice early on!

Shortage

Bill
October 3, 2012
As a young operator we do not even get the chance to work as the experienced folks always get first crack even if they are inferior operators. If only I knew then what I know now...

labor shortage ???

Rickie
October 8, 2012
labor shortage my .........

Replacement workers

Cliff Culhane
October 10, 2012
I have to respectfully disagree with the statements and premise made in this article. The shortage you purport is the result of a conscious choice made by management across this industry. This paradigm was started years ago and is now finally catching up to bite the industry right in the pocket. There is no shortage of support that shows companies would rather save money in hiring low skilled, unskilled or recent graduates to fill positions in the hopes these folks can be trained and turned around in a short period of time. While this would have been fine in the past, schedules and budgets do not adequately support on the job training any longer. There is not enough time in the day and no one wants to pay for it. Companies would rather work with a smaller crew size than bring on a contingent of unskilled workers posted alongside the veterans to eventually rise to a position of use and contribution. Certain schools and organizations have reached out to help with training, ABC and AGC to name a few but they also lack funds and support from the industries they are meant to serve. In future, call it what it is. Yes the work force is aging but there is not an insufficient influx and a time honored failed business practice standing in the way of success. Budget for the future, perpetuate what is important to the industry the downside is poor quality and eventual failure. I'm certain, given a choice, the company's stockholders would err on the side of training and smaller returns rather than none at all.

Skilled Workers

Geo1
October 10, 2012
Can you blame anyone for NOT wanting to become involved in an industry that has been so depressed for over 5 years now? Here in New Mexico, the surveying, construction, and engineering jobs have been VERY hard to come by. I'm just BARELY hanging on, and as far as the prophesied "turn around" the government swears is happening right now in these fields, THEY couldn't be more wrong! I don't see it happening until (maybe) early 2015. Just hope my little surveying company can hold out until then with the few good clients I still have. Regards, Wayne D. Fincke Geometric Services Edgewood, NM

Labor shortage?

William
October 11, 2012
Ron, I don't believe for a second that there is a shortage of skilled workers out there. As you might know the market has turned over and the jobs that paid $90K to $100K are now offered at $45K to $60K and that has turned everyone's stomach. The people that were in the industry before are still here and willing to work but at what pay rate? Companies hire at cut throat levels because they have no margin but still cry there is no one available. Non-sense! Pay a decent wage and the flood will come back. The Midwest where I'm from still hires at 1980 rates and only at 3 to 5 year experience levels. There is about 20% unemployment in the trades and many have gone to other parts of the country to find work. If it picks up here those boys will return in a second. Tell us how many "experienced" people with 20+ years of experience over 50 years old you have placed in the last two years. If you have done two I'll be amazed. The market for us sucks and means we will be the last to get back to work, if ever.

Shortage

Tim
October 11, 2012
Steward for local Operators union and I can tell you first hand we are begging for young operators that are needed to replace those retiring soon. Applicant numbers are way down and our contractors not happy.

Shortage

Geo1
October 11, 2012
Tim.... Maybe I'll change professions...Where the hell are you? And how much are you willing to pay an ol' stobknocker??? I'll be right there! LOL!

Shortage

Frank P
October 22, 2012
People need to read. The author speaks of an upcoming shortage of younger talent and fresh talent no the old hcaks commenting that nobody wishes to hire!

Shortage

Dick Turner
October 26, 2012
The market will pick up eventually (2014)and then we will be screwed. The unions are not training and people are leaving the industry. I see big problems ahead.

Multimedia

Videos

Image Galleries

May 2013: Graders

Information for Site Prep’s May 2013 special focus gallery has been provided by the respective manufacturers. For more information on their equipment lines, visit the websites listed under each entry.

See all Equipment Focus galleries.

THE MAGAZINE

Site Prep

2013 May SP issue

May 2013

In this month's issue of Site Prep, learn how to find the right excavator and check out the results from the 2013 Machine Control Report

Table Of Contents Subscribe

The Site Prep Mag Store

heavyConst-2013
Heavy Construction Cost Data 2013 Book

Get costs for all types of heavy construction — from highways, bridges, utilities, rails and marine projects, to sanitary and storm sewer project!

More Products

Clear Seas Research

Clear Seas ResearchWith access to over one million professionals and more than 60 industry-specific publications, Clear Seas Research offers relevant insights from those who know your industry best. Let us customize a market research solution that exceeds your marketing goals.

Site Prep Directory

Use the Directory online to find the site clearing, earthmoving, utilities, and environmental products and services YOU need to find. CLICK HERE to view the directory.

STAY CONNECTED

Facebook logo Twitter logo  LinkedIn logo  YouTube logo